Stoneware vs porcelain is not a choice between a weak clay and a strong one. Both are high-temperature clay bodies that US makers sell for cone 5 to 6 electric kilns and for cone 10, and both can fire dense and tight. The differences are what they are made of, how they feel on the wheel, how much they move in the kiln and how your glazes look. Stoneware is the forgiving everyday clay; porcelain is the white, fine, demanding one.
This comparison is research-based. We did not throw or fire these clays: we compared the makers' own data sheets and product pages from Laguna, Standard Clay, AMACO, Aardvark and Archie Bray. For the single clays in depth, see our stoneware clay and porcelain clay guides. Specs checked November 2026.
Stoneware vs porcelain at a glance
| Feature | Stoneware | Porcelain |
|---|---|---|
| Main ingredients | Ball clays and fire clays with feldspar and silica; often sand or grog | Kaolin (often grolleg) with feldspar and silica; little or no ball clay |
| Cones sold for | Cone 5 to 6 and cone 10; some list cone 5 to 10 | Cone 5 to 6 and cone 8 to 10 |
| Fired color | Cream, buff, gray, brown, red or black | White to gray-white; some creamy white |
| Absorption at the right cone (maker figures) | About 0% to 3% | About 0% to 2%, most under 1% |
| Shrinkage, wet to fired (maker figures) | About 11% to 15% | About 11% to 14% |
| Translucency | No | Yes when thin, for bodies made for it |
| On the wheel | Holds shape, takes water, forgiving | Soft, slick, collapses with too much water |
| Warping risk | Lower | Higher, especially wide flat forms |
| Best for | Learning, everyday ware, large forms, planters | Bright glazes, thin and light-catching pieces, fine detail |
The ranges come from the bodies in the data table below.
What each clay is made of
Stoneware is built around plastic secondary clays such as ball clay and fire clay, which carry some iron and other minerals. That is why it fires cream to brown and why it throws so easily. Makers add feldspar to melt the body together and silica for glaze fit, and many add sand or grog for texture and strength.
Porcelain is built around kaolin, a purer white clay that is less plastic. Feldspar does more of the work, so a lot of the body turns to glass in the firing. Standard Clay says its 365 and 257 Grolleg Porcelains contain no ball clay, which keeps them white but makes them less plastic on the wheel. More plastic porcelains, such as Laguna's #16, which Laguna calls very plastic, trade a little whiteness for easier throwing.
Firing range: both come in cone 6 and cone 10
A common belief is that porcelain always needs a hotter kiln. It used to, but US makers now sell plenty of mid-fire porcelain for home electric kilns. The cone on the box matters far more than the word stoneware or porcelain.
- Cone 5 to 6 stoneware: Laguna B-Mix 5 (WC401), AMACO No. 46 Buff (best at cone 5), AMACO No. 16 White Chocolate, Standard 182 Angel White (cone 6 to 10), Aardvark Bee Mix 5 and SBF.
- Cone 5 to 6 porcelain: Laguna Frost (WC437) and #16 (WC617), Standard 365 Grolleg and 213, Aardvark Nara 5, Archie Bray Cone 6 Porcelain.
- Cone 10 stoneware: Laguna B-Mix 10 (WC379), AMACO No. 38 White (best at cone 10), Aardvark KGBS and Vegas Buff.
- Cone 8 to 10 porcelain: Standard 257 Grolleg, Aardvark Coleman Porcelain and Nara Porcelain.
On Orton's chart for self-supporting cones at 108°F per hour, cone 5 is 2,167°F (1,186°C), cone 6 is 2,232°F (1,222°C) and cone 10 is 2,345°F (1,285°C). Our pottery cone chart has the full table. Under-firing hurts either clay: AMACO lists No. 38 stoneware at 7% absorption at cone 5 against 1.4% at cone 10, so a cone 10 body in a cone 6 kiln stays porous.
Absorption and vitrification: what the data sheets say
Absorption is the share of water a fired test bar soaks up. The lower it is, the more fully the body has vitrified (melted into a tight, partly glassy mass), and the less a mug will weep or a planter will soak up water. Here is what the makers publish for the bodies above.
| Clay body | Type | Cone | Shrinkage | Absorption | Fired color (maker) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Laguna B-Mix 5 (WC401) | Stoneware | 5 | 12% | 2.3% | Cream in oxidation |
| AMACO No. 46 Buff | Stoneware | 5 (range 5 to 10) | 12% at 5 | 1.8% at 5; 0% at 10 | Buff at 5, soft gray at 10 |
| AMACO No. 16 White Chocolate | Stoneware | 5 to 6 | 13.9% at 6 | 0.3% at 6 | Creamy tone; fired color not published |
| Standard 182 Angel White | Stoneware | 6 to 10 | 11.0% at 6 | 3.0% at 6; 1.5% at 10 | Near white |
| Aardvark Bee Mix 5 | Stoneware | 5 | 12% | 2.5% | Off-white |
| Laguna B-Mix 10 (WC379) | Stoneware | 10 | 13% | 1% | Gray-white in reduction |
| Aardvark KGBS | Stoneware | 10 | 12% | 0% | Gray |
| Laguna Frost (WC437) | Porcelain | 6 | 11% | 0.5% | White, translucent |
| Laguna #16 (WC617) | Porcelain | 6 (title says ^5) | 13.9% | 0.12% | Very light gray wet |
| Standard 365 Grolleg | Porcelain | 6 | 13.5% | 0.35% | White, translucent when thin |
| Standard 213 | Porcelain | 6 | 12.0% | 2.0% | White |
| Aardvark Nara 5 | Porcelain | 5 | 12% | 1.1% | Gray-white (product page), white (spec sheet) |
| Archie Bray Cone 6 Porcelain | Porcelain | 6 | 11% | 1% | Creamy white in oxidation |
| Standard 257 Grolleg | Porcelain | 8 to 10 | 14.0% at 10 | 0.75% at 8; 0.5% at 10 | White, translucent |
| Aardvark Coleman Porcelain | Porcelain | 10 | 13.5% | 0% | White |
Two things stand out. First, porcelain is usually tighter, but not always: AMACO's White Chocolate stoneware lists 0.3% at cone 6, lower than Standard's 213 Porcelain at 2.0% and Archie Bray's Cone 6 Porcelain at 1%. Second, the cone matters as much as the type: Standard 182 drops from 3.0% at cone 6 to 1.5% at cone 10.
Aardvark's spec sheet gives its shrinkage figures as plus or minus 2% and absorption as plus or minus 1%. Aardvark's spec sheet lists Nara 5 as white, while its cone 5/6 product page calls it gray-white. Laguna's #16 page title says ^5 while its spec field says cone 6. Treat every figure as a guide and test at your own cone and firing schedule.
Shrinkage, warping and drying
Shrinkage overlaps more than most people expect. In the table, stoneware runs 11% to 15% and porcelain 11% to 14%, so a porcelain does not automatically shrink more. Laguna's Frost is one of the lowest bodies listed, at 11%.
Movement is the bigger difference. Because so much of porcelain turns to glass, it softens more at the top of the firing, and wide plates and flared bowls can slump or go oval. Stoneware has more unmelted material holding it up, so it keeps its shape better. Porcelain also cracks at rims and bases more readily if it dries unevenly, so it needs slow, covered drying. Plan for one body's shrinkage when you make lids, sets or anything that must fit.
On the wheel and at the table: how they handle
Stoneware is the easier clay to learn on. It takes water, stands up through several pulls and forgives an uneven hand. Grogged stonewares suit slabs, coils and large pieces because thick walls dry and fire more evenly.
Porcelain feels smooth and slick, and it turns to slurry fast if you use much water. It throws thin and light but tears more easily at soft leather hard, and joins need to be made at the same moisture level. Many potters learn on stoneware first and then move to a plastic porcelain such as Laguna #16. Our porcelain throwing tips page goes step by step.
Color, glazes and translucency
Porcelain's white body makes glazes brighter and clearer. Celadons, clears and pale transparent glazes look the way they do on the maker's white test tile, and underglaze colors stay true. Thin porcelain made for translucency, such as Laguna Frost and Standard 365 or 257, lets light through.
Stoneware gives a warmer base. Buff, speckled and brown bodies show iron flecks and darken through transparent glazes, which many potters prefer for rustic or earthy ware. White stonewares such as Laguna B-Mix 5 or Standard 182 get close to porcelain's brightness while keeping stoneware handling. Glaze fit varies body by body: Laguna lists a COE of 7.14 for Frost and 6.07 for B-Mix 5, so a glaze that fits one may craze or shiver on the other. Use glazes rated for your cone and test each new body; see our cone 6 glazes guide.
Strength, chips and everyday use
Both clays make durable everyday ware when fired to their maturing cone. Dinnerware makers such as Lenox describe porcelain as the more durable of the two, but thin porcelain rims can still chip, and thick stoneware takes knocks well but weighs more. Wall thickness, glaze fit and the right cone matter more than the word on the box.
Both can crack from sudden temperature changes, so neither should go from the fridge straight into a hot oven. If you want ovenware, look for it on the maker's list of uses: Laguna lists ovenware among the applications for B-Mix 5 and B-Mix 10, but not for Frost or #16. Food safety depends on the glaze as well as the clay; a maker's label describes their own test results, not your pots, so fire to the stated cone and test.
Cost and buying
Porcelain usually costs more per pound, but the gap varies by maker. On the makers' own price lists in November 2026, before shipping:
- Laguna: Frost and #16 porcelain list at about $1.20 to $1.40 per lb, sold in 50 lb steps; both showed as sold out when we checked.
- Aardvark: cone 5 stonewares list at about $17 to $26 per 25 lb bag, with Nara 5 porcelain just above that range (Nara 5 showed as out of stock).
- Archie Bray: its Cone 6 Porcelain works out to roughly $0.95 to $1.05 per lb in a 50 lb box.
- AMACO: No. 16 White Chocolate stoneware sells in 20 lb boxes of 5 lb blocks and works out to about $2 to $2.20 per lb, more than several porcelains.
Freight often costs more than the price gap, so a nearby dealer can matter more than the clay type. Check the live price. Our how much does clay cost guide covers per-pound budgets and why porcelain runs higher.
Can you use both in one studio?
Yes, with a few rules. Fire them together only if both bodies are rated for the same cone. Keep separate reclaim buckets, because a mixed body has untested shrinkage and fit and loses porcelain's whiteness. Clean the wheel and tools when you switch, since stoneware grit shows in porcelain. Join only like with like, as the two bodies shrink differently.
Where does earthenware fit? It is the third main group, fired much lower and left more porous. Our stoneware vs earthenware comparison covers that choice, and types of pottery clay explains all three.
Safety: both clays contain crystalline silica, and porcelain dust is very fine. Laguna's product pages carry a California Prop 65 warning for crystalline silica. Wet clean your studio, never dry sweep, and wear a NIOSH-approved respirator when you mix dry clay or handle dry scraps. Kilns get hot on the outside and need the clearance and ventilation set out in the maker's manual.
Choose stoneware or porcelain
Choose stoneware if
- You are learning to center and throw, or you hand-build slabs and coils.
- You want warm, speckled or earthy surfaces, or you make planters and larger forms.
- You want the most choice at your kiln's cone and a lower price per pound from most makers.
- You fire a cone 6 kiln and want a body with a long track record, such as Laguna B-Mix 5 or AMACO No. 46.
Choose porcelain if
- You want the brightest glaze color, true underglaze color or translucent thin pieces.
- You already throw well and can work with little water and slow, even drying.
- You make small to medium pieces, cups, jewelry or tiles rather than wide platters.
- Your kiln reaches the body's cone, for example cone 6 for Laguna Frost or Standard 365.
What you need
Whichever you choose, buy a body rated for your kiln's top cone, glazes rated for the same cone, and a 25 lb box to test before you commit. Our best clay for pottery guide compares stoneware and porcelain bodies, and the best kilns for home pottery guide covers cone 6 and cone 10 kilns.
Sources: Laguna Clay product pages for WC401 B-Mix 5, WC379 B-Mix 10, WC437 Frost and WC617 #16 Porcelain (cone, shrinkage, absorption, COE, applications, price, Prop 65 notice); Standard Clay product pages for 182 Angel White, 213 Porcelain, 257 Grolleg Porcelain and 365 Grolleg Porcelain, and its Porcelain and White Stoneware collection; AMACO product pages for No. 46 Buff Stoneware, No. 38 White Stoneware and No. 16 White Chocolate; Aardvark Clay clay specifications sheet and cone 5/6 clay listing; Archie Bray Clay Cone 6 Porcelain product page; Orton pyrometric cone chart (self-supporting cones, 108°F per hour); Lenox and Made In dinnerware guides; Wikipedia entry on bone china. Specs checked November 2026.